A badly handled dispute between shareholders can destroy in a few months the value a business has taken years to build: blocked decisions, accounts not approved, a contested manager, worried banks. Yet French company law offers a full range of solutions, from structured negotiation to court-ordered dissolution, including mechanisms that many shareholders are unaware of. This guide maps them out, taking into account a recent change that practitioners can no longer ignore: since 1 October 2025, the reform of the rules on the nullity of corporate decisions has changed how general meeting resolutions can be challenged.
Identify the nature of the dispute before choosing the weapon
Not all shareholder disputes are alike, and the effective solution depends entirely on the configuration at hand. Deadlock in a company owned 50/50 (in French) paralyses decision-making without either shareholder being able to impose their will on the other. Majority domination, conversely, sees a shareholder or a majority bloc govern alone, decide whether to pay dividends, set remuneration and sideline the minority. Minority blocking occurs when a shareholder holding a blocking minority refuses to vote for a vital decision, such as a capital increase necessary for the company’s survival. To these must be added disputes over the manager (contested management, remuneration, unfair competition) and the case of the shareholder who has become passive, no longer contributing but intending to keep their rights.
Before taking any action, a legal diagnosis is essential. It rests on three readings: the articles of association (approval, exclusion and pre-emption clauses, majority rules), the shareholders’ agreement if there is one (exit clauses, share transfer undertakings, review clauses), and the map of the share capital (who holds what, with which voting rights, and what can be expected at a general meeting). This diagnosis determines the real balance of power, which often differs from the apparent one: a well-advised minority shareholder has levers that the majority underestimates, and vice versa.
The legal form matters just as much. The SAS (simplified joint-stock company) is governed by freedom of contract in its articles, which makes reading them absolutely decisive. The SARL (limited liability company) follows a more rigid statutory regime. Civil companies (in particular property-holding SCIs) offer a right of withdrawal that commercial companies do not. Each section below specifies these differences where necessary.
Finally, time rarely works in favour of the shareholder who waits. At the first signs of crisis, two reflexes are essential. The first is preserving evidence: keep notices of meetings, minutes, written exchanges and accounting documents, because company disputes are won on documents, and access to documents becomes harder precisely once the dispute has broken out. The second is watching time limits: some actions become time-barred quickly, and the reform in force since 1 October 2025 has reduced to two years the period for bringing an action to annul a corporate decision, as explained below. Waiting for the situation to “settle down” often means letting your own rights lapse.
Amicable and contractual solutions: always to be explored first
Negotiation and mediation
A negotiated exit remains statistically the fastest route and the one that destroys the least value. It requires building a file before negotiating: a serious valuation of the company, an analysis of each side’s wrongs, and identification of each party’s legal pressure points. A negotiation conducted without preparation generally ends in an unfavourable sale price or a stalemate. Mediation, conducted by an independent third party, can unblock situations where the personal dimension of the dispute (common between former friends or members of the same family) makes direct dialogue impossible. It has the advantage of confidentiality, whereas litigation exposes the dispute to employees, customers and banks.
Enforcing the shareholders’ agreement
Where there is a shareholders’ agreement, it often contains the solution: a tag-along clause, cross put and call options, or a “buy or sell” clause (also known as a shotgun or Texas clause), under which one shareholder offers to buy the other’s shares at a given price, the other having the choice between selling at that price or buying on the same terms. These mechanisms, designed precisely for deadlock situations, can be enforced: breach of a shareholders’ agreement gives rise to damages and, under certain conditions, to specific performance of the promised transfer. Before any litigation, the first question is therefore: what does the agreement say, and can it be triggered?
Amicable sale and price set by an expert
Many amicable exits founder not on the principle but on the price. Here French law offers a decisive tool: Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code. Where the law or the articles of association refer to this provision, the value of the shares is determined, in the event of dispute, by an expert appointed by the parties or, failing agreement, by the president of the court ruling under the expedited procedure on the merits, with no possibility of appeal. Since the 2019 reform, the expert must apply the valuation rules and methods laid down in the articles or in any agreement binding the parties: the drafting of valuation clauses therefore has a direct effect on the exit price. This is a major point of vigilance, both when drafting the articles and when considering a sale.
The minority shareholder’s remedies against the majority
The right to information and the court-ordered management audit
A minority shareholder who suspects that the company is being managed against the corporate interest is not without recourse. In addition to the information rights attached to each legal form (disclosure of the accounts, written questions), the French Commercial Code provides for the court-ordered management audit (expertise de gestion), sometimes called the minority audit. In an SARL, one or more shareholders holding at least one tenth of the share capital may apply to the court for the appointment of an expert to report on one or more management transactions (Article L. 223-37 of the Commercial Code). In companies limited by shares, shareholders holding at least 5% of the capital first put written questions to the chairman about management transactions; if no satisfactory answer is received within one month, they may apply in summary proceedings for the appointment of an expert (Article L. 225-231). The expert’s report, which is sent in particular to the statutory auditor and appended to the documents for the next general meeting, is often the centrepiece of the litigation to come. Pre-action evidence measures may also be sought under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure where the conditions for a management audit are not met.
Abuse of majority: challenging general meeting resolutions
The minority shareholder’s main weapon remains abuse of majority. According to settled case law, recently restated by the commercial chamber of the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation), a corporate decision amounts to an abuse of majority where it is taken contrary to the general interest of the company and with the sole aim of favouring the members of the majority to the detriment of the minority. These two conditions are cumulative and the burden of proof lies on the party alleging the abuse, as the Supreme Court recalled when it overturned a Court of Appeal judgment that had reversed the burden of proof (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508). Classic examples are the systematic retention of profits with no investment policy to justify it, excessive remuneration for the majority manager, and agreements with companies linked to the majority shareholders.
The sanction is twofold: annulment of the decision and, where appropriate, an order against the majority shareholders to pay damages. On procedure, the Supreme Court has specified that an action to annul a resolution for abuse of majority, where it is not combined with a claim for damages against the majority shareholders, is brought against the company without the majority shareholders having to be joined (Cass. com., 9 July 2025, No. 23-23.484). The claim for damages is time-barred after five years (Cass. com., 6 May 2026, No. 25-11.498).
The framework for such challenges has also been thoroughly overhauled. Ordinance No. 2025-229 of 12 March 2025, in force since 1 October 2025, rewrote the rules on nullity in company law. The new Article 1844-10 of the Civil Code provides that corporate decisions can only be annulled for breach of a mandatory provision of company law or on one of the grounds for the nullity of contracts in general, and that, unless the law provides otherwise, a breach of the articles of association is not a ground for nullity. Another major change: actions to annul corporate decisions are now time-barred after two years (Article 1844-14 of the Civil Code), instead of three previously. Any strategy for challenging a general meeting must therefore be calibrated, and above all launched, faster than before.
Claims against the manager
Where the dispute centres on management, the minority shareholder may bring a liability claim against the manager. Alongside the individual action, reserved for personal loss distinct from that of the company, the derivative action (action ut singuli) allows a shareholder to act on behalf of the company to obtain compensation for the loss caused to it by mismanagement. Removing the manager (in French) follows rules specific to each legal form and gives rise to its own disputes, between the requirement of a valid reason and compensation for wrongful removal.
Responses to a deadlocked company
The special case of 50/50 shareholders
A company owned in equal shares by two shareholders (or two blocs) is the most exposed configuration: no decision can be imposed, and the first serious disagreement can turn into complete paralysis. Since neither shareholder is in the majority or the minority, the notions of abuse of majority and abuse of minority give way to that of abuse of equality, which the case law treats in the same way as abuse of minority: a systematic refusal to vote, contrary to the corporate interest and driven by personal interest, can be sanctioned and overcome by the appointment of an officer to vote in place of the blocking shareholder. In practice, the way out of a 50/50 deadlock almost always involves one of the following mechanisms: the buy or sell clause in the shareholders’ agreement where there is one, a negotiated buy-out backed by an expert valuation, the appointment of an interim administrator to keep the business running during negotiations and, as a very last resort, dissolution on the grounds of disagreement. This is the area par excellence where pre-litigation strategy (who issues proceedings first, on what basis, with what evidence) determines the economic outcome.
Abuse of minority and the court-appointed officer
Blocking can come from below: a minority shareholder holding a blocking minority refuses to vote for an amendment to the articles that is essential to the company’s survival, such as a capital increase required by law or by the financial situation. The case law characterises as abuse of minority conduct that is contrary to the general interest of the company and adopted with the sole aim of favouring one’s own interests to the detriment of the other shareholders. The sanction has a particular feature: the court cannot declare the resolution adopted, but it can appoint an officer (mandataire ad hoc) to vote in place of the defaulting minority shareholder at a new general meeting, in addition to ordering the minority shareholder to pay damages.
The interim administrator, a crisis measure
Where the dispute escalates to the point of jeopardising day-to-day management, any interested party may apply to the court for the appointment of an interim administrator (administrateur provisoire). The case law makes this serious measure subject to strict conditions: there must be circumstances making the normal operation of the company impossible and threatening it with imminent danger. The interim administrator takes over from the managers in office, which makes the measure both a remedy and a weapon: the appointment profoundly changes the balance of power. A mandataire ad hoc, a lighter measure, makes it possible to entrust a third party with a specific task (convening a general meeting, representing the company for a particular act) without removing the corporate bodies.
Court-ordered dissolution for disagreement, the ultimate solution
Article 1844-7, 5° of the Civil Code allows the court to order the early dissolution (in French) of the company at the request of a shareholder, for just cause, in particular where a shareholder fails to perform their obligations or where disagreement between shareholders paralyses the functioning of the company. The provision is strictly applied: disagreement, however deep, is not enough; it must be shown that it actually paralyses the functioning of the company. A company that continues to operate, invoice and hold its meetings will not be dissolved, however much relations between shareholders have deteriorated. The case law also refuses the action to the shareholder who caused the disagreement. The courts, aware that dissolution destroys the business and its jobs, reserve it for situations with no way out: it is argued as an ultimate solution and in practice often serves as leverage to negotiate an organised exit.
Making a shareholder leave, or leaving yourself
Excluding a shareholder
Contrary to a widespread belief, you cannot exclude a shareholder (in French) simply because the relationship has broken down. Exclusion requires a basis in statute or in the articles. The SAS offers the most flexible framework: Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code allows the articles to provide that a shareholder may be required to sell their shares on the conditions they set, with the possibility of suspending their non-financial rights until the sale. The French Constitutional Council has held this mechanism to be constitutional (Decision No. 2022-1029 QPC of 9 December 2022). The exclusion clause must still exist, define grounds and a procedure, and be implemented in good faith: exclusion disputes almost always turn on the regularity of the procedure and respect for the right to be heard. In SARLs and civil companies, exclusion also rests on clauses in the articles or on mechanisms in the shareholders’ agreement (share transfer undertakings triggered by the end of the shareholder’s functions, good and bad leaver clauses).
Withdrawal and sale
Conversely, a shareholder who wants to leave cannot always do so freely. In civil companies, Article 1869 of the Civil Code gives a right of withdrawal: under the conditions laid down in the articles, with the unanimous agreement of the other shareholders or, failing that, with the court’s authorisation for just cause, the withdrawing shareholder is entitled to repayment of the value of their shares, set, failing agreement, in accordance with Article 1843-4. Commercial companies have no equivalent statutory right of withdrawal: a minority shareholder in an SARL or SAS who wants to leave must sell their shares (in French), dealing with approval and pre-emption clauses, or trigger the mechanisms of the shareholders’ agreement. Depending on the legal form, however, a refusal of approval triggers an obligation to buy back the shares. It is precisely because exit is never guaranteed that negotiation, backed by credible litigation levers, remains the necessary route in most cases.
What happens to the shareholder loan account
The shareholder loan account (compte courant d’associé) is a recurring point of friction when shareholders part ways. Unless otherwise agreed (a lock-up clause or loan account agreement), the shareholder can demand repayment at any time, and their status as creditor survives the loss of their status as shareholder. In negotiating an exit, repayment of the loan account is therefore dealt with separately from the sale price of the shares, and is often a lever in its own right.
Before which court, and under which procedure?
Disputes relating to commercial companies (in particular SARLs, SASs and SAs) fall within the jurisdiction of the commercial court (Article L. 721-3 of the Commercial Code), including disputes between shareholders relating to the life of the company. Disputes between shareholders of civil companies, first and foremost SCIs, fall within the jurisdiction of the civil court (tribunal judiciaire). Since 1 January 2025, an experiment provided for by Law No. 2023-1059 of 20 November 2023 has turned twelve commercial courts into Economic Activities Courts (tribunaux des activités économiques), with extended jurisdiction, mainly for dealing with businesses in difficulty; a contribution to economic justice is payable in certain cases by the largest claimant companies. For a shareholder dispute, however, the essential point remains the classic division between commercial court and civil court, with one caveat: the articles or the shareholders’ agreement frequently contain an arbitration clause, which submits the dispute to arbitration, as Article L. 721-3 expressly allows.
Summary proceedings play a central role in this type of litigation: appointment of an interim administrator or a mandataire ad hoc, evidence measures, escrow of disputed shares. The time taken by proceedings on the merits (often eighteen months to two years at first instance) is rarely compatible with the pace of a company in crisis, and the litigation strategy in a shareholder dispute is built precisely on the interplay between urgent measures, actions on the merits and continuous negotiation.
A final word on method: in this type of litigation more than any other, court action is not an end in itself but an instrument serving an economic objective, which is almost always the exit of one of the shareholders on acceptable financial terms, or regaining control of the company. Every step (a management audit, an application to appoint an interim administrator, an action for annulment) changes the balance of power and the parties’ negotiating position. The best-run cases are those in which every litigation initiative has been designed with the negotiating table in mind, and not the other way round.
Preventing the next dispute: the shareholders’ agreement
Almost all the disputes described above would have been avoided, or resolved within a few weeks, by a well-drafted shareholders’ agreement. The decisive clauses are well known: a buy or sell clause to resolve 50/50 deadlocks, share transfer undertakings in the event of departure or misconduct (good leaver, bad leaver), tag-along and drag-along clauses, a mandatory prior mediation clause, precise valuation rules that will bind the expert under Article 1843-4, and temporary lock-up clauses to stabilise the share capital. Drafting or updating a shareholders’ agreement while everyone is still getting along costs infinitely less than the first month of a shareholder dispute.
FAQ: your questions on shareholder disputes
How can a dispute between shareholders be resolved?
In stages: a legal diagnosis (articles, shareholders’ agreement, distribution of the share capital), then amicable solutions (negotiation, mediation, buy-out of shares), then court action if necessary: management audit, action for abuse of majority or minority, interim administrator and, as a last resort, court-ordered dissolution.
Can a shareholder be excluded from the company?
Only if a clause or a statutory provision allows it. In an SAS, Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code allows the articles to provide for the compulsory sale of a shareholder’s shares. Without an exclusion clause, a shareholder cannot be forced out against their will, however serious the dispute.
How can I leave a company when shareholders disagree?
Through an amicable sale of your shares, enforcement of the shareholders’ agreement, court-authorised withdrawal for just cause in civil companies (Article 1869 of the Civil Code), or court-ordered dissolution if the disagreement paralyses the company. If the price is disputed, it can be set by an expert (Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code).
What is abuse of majority?
A decision taken contrary to the general interest of the company and with the sole aim of favouring the majority to the detriment of the minority. The burden of proof lies on the party alleging it. Sanctions: annulment of the decision and damages.
When can dissolution of the company for disagreement be sought?
When the disagreement paralyses the functioning of the company (Article 1844-7, 5° of the Civil Code): general meetings impossible to hold, accounts not approved, corporate bodies blocked. The courts order it sparingly and refuse it to the shareholder who caused the disagreement.
Which court has jurisdiction over a dispute between shareholders?
The commercial court for commercial companies (Article L. 721-3 of the Commercial Code), the civil court for civil companies such as SCIs. An arbitration clause in the articles or the shareholders’ agreement may submit the dispute to arbitration.
In a dispute with one or more fellow shareholders, or sensing a crisis coming? We act both in an advisory capacity and in litigation: diagnosis of your situation (articles, shareholders’ agreement, balance of power), exit or takeover strategy, urgent measures and negotiation. Contact us for an initial confidential discussion.
