Published on 16 July 2026 · Online reputation · Technology litigation
A rating that collapses, reviews from strangers who have never set foot in your premises, false accusations on the first page of Google: for a retailer, a practitioner or a company, fake reviews translate directly into lost customers. The good news is that French law does not tolerate them: the courts order their removal, identify their authors and hold them liable. The less good news is that everything turns on the evidence. An explanation, with case law.
Fake reviews: one scourge, several types of author
The Google business listing (Google Business Profile, formerly Google My Business) has become professionals’ main shop window: it is what appears, with its five-star rating, when someone searches for a restaurant, a tradesperson, a doctor or a lawyer. Anyone can post a review there without having to prove they were actually a customer. This system, valuable when it works fairly, is also a weapon: a handful of one-star reviews is enough to bring a rating down and drive customers away.
Behind fake reviews there are almost always the same profiles: the competitor trying to win customers; the former employee or ousted shareholder settling scores; the person in a personal dispute with the manager, posing as a disappointed customer; the outfits selling review campaigns, positive or negative; and sometimes ordinary internet users who were never customers but are joining in a controversy. In a case decided in Paris, the author of six fake reviews targeting a renovation company turned out to be someone in a personal dispute with its manager, who had never been a customer (Paris Civil Court, 17th chamber, press and civil, 22 June 2022).
Critical review or unlawful review: where is the line?
Not every negative review is unlawful, far from it. A genuinely disappointed customer has the right to say so, even harshly: criticism is protected by freedom of expression, and the courts regularly point out that the right to criticise “must not degenerate into abuse where the criticism takes the form of disparagement, reflects obvious animosity or is motivated by a desire to cause harm” (to this effect, Évreux Civil Court, summary proceedings, 4 March 2026, No. 25/00469). This fine line structures the entire body of case law.
The following fall on the unlawful side:
- the fake review proper, from someone who has never been a customer and describes an invented experience: it is wrongful by nature, whatever its content;
- the disparaging review, which discredits the professional’s products or services in an excessive or malicious way: it gives rise to the author’s civil liability (Article 1240 of the French Civil Code);
- the defamatory or insulting review, which attacks the person (alleging a specific fact that harms their honour, or abuse): it then falls under the French Press Law of 29 July 1881, with its own rules, including a three-month limitation period.
This distinction between disparagement (criticism of products and services, governed by the general law of tort) and defamation (an attack on a person’s honour, governed by the 1881 Law) is not an academic subtlety: it determines the legal basis of the action, the procedure and the time limits. Choosing the wrong ground exposes the claim to being declared inadmissible. It is one of the first points a lawyer checks before taking action.
Publishing fake reviews is a criminal offence
Since the transposition of the “Omnibus” Directive, the French Consumer Code expressly lists fake reviews among the commercial practices deemed misleading in all circumstances: Article L. 121-4 covers stating that reviews come from consumers who have actually used or purchased the product without having checked this (27°) and “disseminating or causing to be disseminated fake consumer reviews or recommendations, or modifying consumer reviews or recommendations” in order to promote products (28°).
The penalties are heavy: two years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, increased to five years’ imprisonment and a €750,000 fine where the practice is committed online (Article L. 132-2 of the French Consumer Code, as amended by the Law of 10 May 2024), and the fine may also be increased to 10% of turnover. The DGCCRF, the French consumer protection and fraud authority, regularly investigates and imposes penalties in this area. This criminal dimension is not just a theoretical threat: as we will see, it is also the key to obtaining the identification of anonymous authors.
Step 1: report the review to Google, a useful but rarely sufficient first step
Google provides a tool for reporting reviews that breach its rules (false or misleading content, conflicts of interest, harassment, offensive language), accessible from the business listing, and the EU Digital Services Act (DSA) requires it to process reports of unlawful content diligently. This report should be made, with careful reasons, because it is quick and free and it prepares the court file.
Its limits should nevertheless be understood. Google, as a hosting provider, does not judge whether a review is true: it only removes of its own accord what clearly breaches its rules, and reviews that are merely untruthful or disparaging often slip through the net. A French Court of Appeal noted, in a case of disparagement through a Google listing, that a removal request to Google “would not succeed, since disparaging statements do not appear on the list drawn up by Google of content that may be reported” (Douai Court of Appeal, 2nd chamber, 16 May 2024, No. 23/04404).
As for the professional’s public reply under the review, it is useful to put things on record (“no customer of that name in our records”) but must remain measured, and professionals bound by confidentiality (doctors, lawyers, notaries) must take care not to reveal anything about their relationship with any genuine client.
Step 2: take legal action against Google, to remove and to identify
When reporting fails, two claims can be brought before the court, often in the same proceedings against Google Ireland Limited (the entity that operates the service in Europe): removal of the unlawful reviews and disclosure of the data identifying their authors.
The procedural vehicle now favoured is the expedited procedure on the merits under Article 6-3 of the LCEN (the French Law on Confidence in the Digital Economy): the president of the civil court may order any person able to contribute, including Google as hosting provider, to take “all measures appropriate to prevent damage or to stop damage caused by the content of an online public communication service”. Removal and identification can be sought together, and the civil courts now regularly hear such cases concerning reviews: a fake review campaign targeting a professional (Paris Civil Court, 19 March 2025, No. 24/58239); a practitioner targeted by fake reviews from supposed patients, seeking removal and identification data in the same proceedings (Paris Civil Court, 10 October 2025, No. 25/52961); disputed reviews on the listing of a wealth management firm (Lyon Civil Court, 13 November 2023, No. 23/00640); a health centre and practitioner acting against Google under Article 6-3 as amended by the SREN Law of 21 May 2024 (Lyon Civil Court, 3 March 2025, No. 24/09477). Ordinary summary proceedings and ex parte applications remain available, in particular to obtain evidence under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Removal of unlawful reviews
Whether ruling in summary proceedings or under the expedited procedure on the merits, the court orders the removal of a review where its unlawful nature is established with the required degree of obviousness (a manifestly unlawful disturbance in summary proceedings, damage justifying the measure under Article 6-3). The case law offers several examples: removal of a manifestly insulting review ordered against Google (Paris Regional Court, summary proceedings, 11 July 2019, concerning a dentist’s listing); an order in summary proceedings to stop systematic disparagement organised through a business listing (Douai Court of Appeal, 16 May 2024, cited above); removal of a disparaging review posted by one professional about another (Paris Court of Appeal, division 5 chamber 11, 21 October 2022, No. 21/04183); and removal ordered in summary proceedings of a disparaging review whose author was identified (Lille Civil Court, summary proceedings, 16 June 2026, No. 26/00532).
Identifying anonymous authors
Fake reviews are almost always posted under a pseudonym or a false identity. The court can then order Google to disclose the identification data associated with the accounts, under the expedited procedure on the merits of Article 6-3 of the LCEN, or on an ex parte application or in summary proceedings under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: any first name and surname entered, Gmail address, recovery addresses, IP addresses used to create the account and for the most recent logins. The Paris Court of Appeal thus upheld an order requiring Google to disclose the identification data of the accounts behind a wave of nine fake reviews targeting a doctor (Paris Court of Appeal, division 4 chamber 10, 26 September 2024, No. 21/11185).
This data does not always lead directly to a name: a second step is then needed with the electronic communications operators to identify the subscriber behind the connection. This mechanism, which we describe in detail in our article on identifying the authors of online offences (in French), works: in the case decided in Paris on 22 June 2022, it was the combination of data from Google and from the operators Orange and Transatel, obtained through ex parte orders, that exposed the author of the six fake reviews.
An important technical point: since the Law of 30 July 2021, hosting providers only retain identification data for the purposes of criminal proceedings. The request for disclosure must therefore be framed around a future criminal action, which is precisely what the classification of fake reviews as a misleading commercial practice allows, combined where appropriate with other offences (false accusation, online harassment in the case of a campaign of repeated reviews).
The burden of proof is the condition of success. Being convinced that you are the victim of fake reviews is never enough: you have to prove it. The Paris Court of Appeal thus dismissed all the claims of a notary who argued that five negative reviews were fake: the reviews had been posted over several months, two of them were reasoned and nuanced, their authors had rated other professionals, and there was no concrete evidence pointing to competitors. The court held that the reviews were legitimate criticism, refused to lift their anonymity for lack of a legitimate reason and ordered the claimant to pay Google’s costs (Paris Court of Appeal, division 1 chamber 8, 27 April 2022, No. 21/14958). Similarly, an insufficiently reasoned identification request was rejected because the interest pursued had not been demonstrated (Paris Civil Court, summary proceedings, 10 October 2025, No. 25/53018). The body of evidence of falsity has to be built: the name is not in the customer file, accounts with no history created in bursts, suspicious timing, similarities in wording, a link with an identified dispute.
Step 3: pursue the author once identified
Once identified, the author is no longer untouchable, and judgments against authors are regular.
- Removal subject to a daily penalty: the court orders the author to remove the reviews personally, failing which a sum is payable for each day of delay (Bordeaux Civil Court, 1st civil chamber, 18 December 2025, No. 24/06043, concerning a review targeting a veterinary clinic; Roanne Commercial Court, summary proceedings, 21 November 2025, No. 2025R00012);
- Damages: in the six fake reviews case decided on 22 June 2022, the author was ordered, for wrongful disparagement, to pay €3,000 for non-pecuniary loss and €4,000 towards legal costs, plus court costs. Economic loss (proven loss of customers) may be added;
- Criminal proceedings: a complaint for misleading commercial practice and, depending on the case, false accusation, insult or defamation, or even online harassment where the reviews form part of a campaign. A report to the DGCCRF is an additional lever, particularly suited to outfits selling review campaigns.
Building the evidence from the first review
In this type of dispute more than any other, the case is won in advance. As soon as suspicious reviews are discovered: have a formal record drawn up by a commissaire de justice (reviews can be edited or deleted at any time, and the evidence with them); document their falsity (an extract from the customer file showing that no customer has that name, the history of the authors’ accounts, the timing of the posts, stylistic similarities); identify the context (an ongoing commercial dispute, an employee’s acrimonious departure, a personal dispute); report to Google and keep a record of the reports and refusals; then act quickly: the connection data needed to trace the authors is only kept for one year, and any defamation claim is time-barred after three months.
Each situation calls for its own strategy: a simple report for an isolated review that clearly breaches Google’s rules, summary proceedings against the author where they are known, proceedings against Google for removal and identification where the attack is anonymous or organised, and a criminal complaint where the scale justifies it. It is this legal and evidential calibration that makes the difference between cases won and claims dismissed.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get a fake Google review removed?
Start by reporting it through Google’s tool and, if Google refuses, send a detailed notice. If the review stays online, a court can order its removal, either by the author personally, subject to a daily penalty, or by Google, in summary proceedings or under the expedited procedure on the merits of Article 6-3 of the LCEN, where the review is unlawful (insulting, untruthful or disparaging). The key is to show, with evidence, that the review is fake or goes beyond legitimate criticism.
Can the anonymous author of a fake Google review be identified?
Yes. The court can order Google, under the expedited procedure on the merits, on an ex parte application or in summary proceedings, to disclose the account’s identification data (name, email address, IP addresses), and then order the telecoms operators to identify the subscriber behind the connection. This is how authors of fake reviews have been identified and held liable. Since 2021, however, this data is only retained for the purposes of criminal proceedings: the request must be framed around an offence, such as a misleading commercial practice.
Does a dissatisfied customer have the right to leave a negative review?
Yes. Criticism from a genuine customer, even harsh, is protected by freedom of expression, and the courts refuse to remove reviews that are merely unfavourable. A review becomes unlawful when it comes from someone who has never been a customer, is based on false facts, is insulting or degenerates into disparagement motivated by a desire to cause harm.
What does the author of a fake review risk?
Under civil law, an order to remove the review subject to a daily penalty and to compensate the victim (damages and legal costs). Under criminal law, disseminating or causing to be disseminated fake consumer reviews is a misleading commercial practice by nature (Article L. 121-4, 27° and 28° of the French Consumer Code), punishable by two years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, increased to five years and €750,000 where it is committed online (Article L. 132-2).
Can Google be forced to remove a review?
Yes, but under strict conditions. Google is a hosting provider: its liability requires content that is manifestly unlawful. The courts have ordered the removal of insulting or disparaging reviews, but refuse to remove reviews that are merely negative where their falsity has not been shown by serious evidence. The evidential file makes all the difference.
Legislation and decisions cited (quotations from French decisions are our translations): Articles L. 121-2 to L. 121-4 and L. 132-2 of the French Consumer Code; Article 1240 of the French Civil Code; Press Law of 29 July 1881; Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure; Article 6 of Law No. 2004-575 of 21 June 2004 (LCEN); Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA); Paris Regional Court, summary proceedings, 11 July 2019; Paris Court of Appeal, division 1 chamber 8, 27 April 2022, No. 21/14958; Paris Civil Court, 17th chamber, press and civil, 22 June 2022; Paris Court of Appeal, division 5 chamber 11, 21 October 2022, No. 21/04183; Douai Court of Appeal, 2nd chamber section 2, 16 May 2024, No. 23/04404; Paris Court of Appeal, division 4 chamber 10, 26 September 2024, No. 21/11185; Lyon Civil Court, 13 November 2023, No. 23/00640; Lyon Civil Court, expedited procedure on the merits, 3 March 2025, No. 24/09477; Paris Civil Court, 19 March 2025, No. 24/58239; Paris Civil Court, expedited procedure on the merits, 10 October 2025, No. 25/52961; Paris Civil Court, summary proceedings, 10 October 2025, No. 25/53018; Roanne Commercial Court, summary proceedings, 21 November 2025, No. 2025R00012; Bordeaux Civil Court, 1st civil chamber, 18 December 2025, No. 24/06043; Évreux Civil Court, summary proceedings, 4 March 2026, No. 25/00469; Lille Civil Court, summary proceedings, 16 June 2026, No. 26/00532.
Fake Google reviews: how to have them removed
Published on 16 July 2026 · Online reputation · Technology litigation
A rating that collapses, reviews from strangers who have never set foot in your premises, false accusations on the first page of Google: for a retailer, a practitioner or a company, fake reviews translate directly into lost customers. The good news is that French law does not tolerate them: the courts order their removal, identify their authors and hold them liable. The less good news is that everything turns on the evidence. An explanation, with case law.
Fake reviews: one scourge, several types of author
The Google business listing (Google Business Profile, formerly Google My Business) has become professionals’ main shop window: it is what appears, with its five-star rating, when someone searches for a restaurant, a tradesperson, a doctor or a lawyer. Anyone can post a review there without having to prove they were actually a customer. This system, valuable when it works fairly, is also a weapon: a handful of one-star reviews is enough to bring a rating down and drive customers away.
Behind fake reviews there are almost always the same profiles: the competitor trying to win customers; the former employee or ousted shareholder settling scores; the person in a personal dispute with the manager, posing as a disappointed customer; the outfits selling review campaigns, positive or negative; and sometimes ordinary internet users who were never customers but are joining in a controversy. In a case decided in Paris, the author of six fake reviews targeting a renovation company turned out to be someone in a personal dispute with its manager, who had never been a customer (Paris Civil Court, 17th chamber, press and civil, 22 June 2022).
Critical review or unlawful review: where is the line?
Not every negative review is unlawful, far from it. A genuinely disappointed customer has the right to say so, even harshly: criticism is protected by freedom of expression, and the courts regularly point out that the right to criticise “must not degenerate into abuse where the criticism takes the form of disparagement, reflects obvious animosity or is motivated by a desire to cause harm” (to this effect, Évreux Civil Court, summary proceedings, 4 March 2026, No. 25/00469). This fine line structures the entire body of case law.
The following fall on the unlawful side:
This distinction between disparagement (criticism of products and services, governed by the general law of tort) and defamation (an attack on a person’s honour, governed by the 1881 Law) is not an academic subtlety: it determines the legal basis of the action, the procedure and the time limits. Choosing the wrong ground exposes the claim to being declared inadmissible. It is one of the first points a lawyer checks before taking action.
Publishing fake reviews is a criminal offence
Since the transposition of the “Omnibus” Directive, the French Consumer Code expressly lists fake reviews among the commercial practices deemed misleading in all circumstances: Article L. 121-4 covers stating that reviews come from consumers who have actually used or purchased the product without having checked this (27°) and “disseminating or causing to be disseminated fake consumer reviews or recommendations, or modifying consumer reviews or recommendations” in order to promote products (28°).
The penalties are heavy: two years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, increased to five years’ imprisonment and a €750,000 fine where the practice is committed online (Article L. 132-2 of the French Consumer Code, as amended by the Law of 10 May 2024), and the fine may also be increased to 10% of turnover. The DGCCRF, the French consumer protection and fraud authority, regularly investigates and imposes penalties in this area. This criminal dimension is not just a theoretical threat: as we will see, it is also the key to obtaining the identification of anonymous authors.
Step 1: report the review to Google, a useful but rarely sufficient first step
Google provides a tool for reporting reviews that breach its rules (false or misleading content, conflicts of interest, harassment, offensive language), accessible from the business listing, and the EU Digital Services Act (DSA) requires it to process reports of unlawful content diligently. This report should be made, with careful reasons, because it is quick and free and it prepares the court file.
Its limits should nevertheless be understood. Google, as a hosting provider, does not judge whether a review is true: it only removes of its own accord what clearly breaches its rules, and reviews that are merely untruthful or disparaging often slip through the net. A French Court of Appeal noted, in a case of disparagement through a Google listing, that a removal request to Google “would not succeed, since disparaging statements do not appear on the list drawn up by Google of content that may be reported” (Douai Court of Appeal, 2nd chamber, 16 May 2024, No. 23/04404).
As for the professional’s public reply under the review, it is useful to put things on record (“no customer of that name in our records”) but must remain measured, and professionals bound by confidentiality (doctors, lawyers, notaries) must take care not to reveal anything about their relationship with any genuine client.
Step 2: take legal action against Google, to remove and to identify
When reporting fails, two claims can be brought before the court, often in the same proceedings against Google Ireland Limited (the entity that operates the service in Europe): removal of the unlawful reviews and disclosure of the data identifying their authors.
The procedural vehicle now favoured is the expedited procedure on the merits under Article 6-3 of the LCEN (the French Law on Confidence in the Digital Economy): the president of the civil court may order any person able to contribute, including Google as hosting provider, to take “all measures appropriate to prevent damage or to stop damage caused by the content of an online public communication service”. Removal and identification can be sought together, and the civil courts now regularly hear such cases concerning reviews: a fake review campaign targeting a professional (Paris Civil Court, 19 March 2025, No. 24/58239); a practitioner targeted by fake reviews from supposed patients, seeking removal and identification data in the same proceedings (Paris Civil Court, 10 October 2025, No. 25/52961); disputed reviews on the listing of a wealth management firm (Lyon Civil Court, 13 November 2023, No. 23/00640); a health centre and practitioner acting against Google under Article 6-3 as amended by the SREN Law of 21 May 2024 (Lyon Civil Court, 3 March 2025, No. 24/09477). Ordinary summary proceedings and ex parte applications remain available, in particular to obtain evidence under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Removal of unlawful reviews
Whether ruling in summary proceedings or under the expedited procedure on the merits, the court orders the removal of a review where its unlawful nature is established with the required degree of obviousness (a manifestly unlawful disturbance in summary proceedings, damage justifying the measure under Article 6-3). The case law offers several examples: removal of a manifestly insulting review ordered against Google (Paris Regional Court, summary proceedings, 11 July 2019, concerning a dentist’s listing); an order in summary proceedings to stop systematic disparagement organised through a business listing (Douai Court of Appeal, 16 May 2024, cited above); removal of a disparaging review posted by one professional about another (Paris Court of Appeal, division 5 chamber 11, 21 October 2022, No. 21/04183); and removal ordered in summary proceedings of a disparaging review whose author was identified (Lille Civil Court, summary proceedings, 16 June 2026, No. 26/00532).
Identifying anonymous authors
Fake reviews are almost always posted under a pseudonym or a false identity. The court can then order Google to disclose the identification data associated with the accounts, under the expedited procedure on the merits of Article 6-3 of the LCEN, or on an ex parte application or in summary proceedings under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: any first name and surname entered, Gmail address, recovery addresses, IP addresses used to create the account and for the most recent logins. The Paris Court of Appeal thus upheld an order requiring Google to disclose the identification data of the accounts behind a wave of nine fake reviews targeting a doctor (Paris Court of Appeal, division 4 chamber 10, 26 September 2024, No. 21/11185).
This data does not always lead directly to a name: a second step is then needed with the electronic communications operators to identify the subscriber behind the connection. This mechanism, which we describe in detail in our article on identifying the authors of online offences (in French), works: in the case decided in Paris on 22 June 2022, it was the combination of data from Google and from the operators Orange and Transatel, obtained through ex parte orders, that exposed the author of the six fake reviews.
An important technical point: since the Law of 30 July 2021, hosting providers only retain identification data for the purposes of criminal proceedings. The request for disclosure must therefore be framed around a future criminal action, which is precisely what the classification of fake reviews as a misleading commercial practice allows, combined where appropriate with other offences (false accusation, online harassment in the case of a campaign of repeated reviews).
The burden of proof is the condition of success. Being convinced that you are the victim of fake reviews is never enough: you have to prove it. The Paris Court of Appeal thus dismissed all the claims of a notary who argued that five negative reviews were fake: the reviews had been posted over several months, two of them were reasoned and nuanced, their authors had rated other professionals, and there was no concrete evidence pointing to competitors. The court held that the reviews were legitimate criticism, refused to lift their anonymity for lack of a legitimate reason and ordered the claimant to pay Google’s costs (Paris Court of Appeal, division 1 chamber 8, 27 April 2022, No. 21/14958). Similarly, an insufficiently reasoned identification request was rejected because the interest pursued had not been demonstrated (Paris Civil Court, summary proceedings, 10 October 2025, No. 25/53018). The body of evidence of falsity has to be built: the name is not in the customer file, accounts with no history created in bursts, suspicious timing, similarities in wording, a link with an identified dispute.
Step 3: pursue the author once identified
Once identified, the author is no longer untouchable, and judgments against authors are regular.
Building the evidence from the first review
In this type of dispute more than any other, the case is won in advance. As soon as suspicious reviews are discovered: have a formal record drawn up by a commissaire de justice (reviews can be edited or deleted at any time, and the evidence with them); document their falsity (an extract from the customer file showing that no customer has that name, the history of the authors’ accounts, the timing of the posts, stylistic similarities); identify the context (an ongoing commercial dispute, an employee’s acrimonious departure, a personal dispute); report to Google and keep a record of the reports and refusals; then act quickly: the connection data needed to trace the authors is only kept for one year, and any defamation claim is time-barred after three months.
Each situation calls for its own strategy: a simple report for an isolated review that clearly breaches Google’s rules, summary proceedings against the author where they are known, proceedings against Google for removal and identification where the attack is anonymous or organised, and a criminal complaint where the scale justifies it. It is this legal and evidential calibration that makes the difference between cases won and claims dismissed.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get a fake Google review removed?
Start by reporting it through Google’s tool and, if Google refuses, send a detailed notice. If the review stays online, a court can order its removal, either by the author personally, subject to a daily penalty, or by Google, in summary proceedings or under the expedited procedure on the merits of Article 6-3 of the LCEN, where the review is unlawful (insulting, untruthful or disparaging). The key is to show, with evidence, that the review is fake or goes beyond legitimate criticism.
Can the anonymous author of a fake Google review be identified?
Yes. The court can order Google, under the expedited procedure on the merits, on an ex parte application or in summary proceedings, to disclose the account’s identification data (name, email address, IP addresses), and then order the telecoms operators to identify the subscriber behind the connection. This is how authors of fake reviews have been identified and held liable. Since 2021, however, this data is only retained for the purposes of criminal proceedings: the request must be framed around an offence, such as a misleading commercial practice.
Does a dissatisfied customer have the right to leave a negative review?
Yes. Criticism from a genuine customer, even harsh, is protected by freedom of expression, and the courts refuse to remove reviews that are merely unfavourable. A review becomes unlawful when it comes from someone who has never been a customer, is based on false facts, is insulting or degenerates into disparagement motivated by a desire to cause harm.
What does the author of a fake review risk?
Under civil law, an order to remove the review subject to a daily penalty and to compensate the victim (damages and legal costs). Under criminal law, disseminating or causing to be disseminated fake consumer reviews is a misleading commercial practice by nature (Article L. 121-4, 27° and 28° of the French Consumer Code), punishable by two years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, increased to five years and €750,000 where it is committed online (Article L. 132-2).
Can Google be forced to remove a review?
Yes, but under strict conditions. Google is a hosting provider: its liability requires content that is manifestly unlawful. The courts have ordered the removal of insulting or disparaging reviews, but refuse to remove reviews that are merely negative where their falsity has not been shown by serious evidence. The evidential file makes all the difference.
A victim of fake reviews or an online disparagement campaign? TOUITOU LAW assists retailers, professionals and companies: reports, actions against Google and review platforms, identification of authors and claims for compensation. Contact us to assess your situation.
Further reading (in French): How to identify the author of an online offence · How to remove content from Google
Legislation and decisions cited (quotations from French decisions are our translations): Articles L. 121-2 to L. 121-4 and L. 132-2 of the French Consumer Code; Article 1240 of the French Civil Code; Press Law of 29 July 1881; Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure; Article 6 of Law No. 2004-575 of 21 June 2004 (LCEN); Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA); Paris Regional Court, summary proceedings, 11 July 2019; Paris Court of Appeal, division 1 chamber 8, 27 April 2022, No. 21/14958; Paris Civil Court, 17th chamber, press and civil, 22 June 2022; Paris Court of Appeal, division 5 chamber 11, 21 October 2022, No. 21/04183; Douai Court of Appeal, 2nd chamber section 2, 16 May 2024, No. 23/04404; Paris Court of Appeal, division 4 chamber 10, 26 September 2024, No. 21/11185; Lyon Civil Court, 13 November 2023, No. 23/00640; Lyon Civil Court, expedited procedure on the merits, 3 March 2025, No. 24/09477; Paris Civil Court, 19 March 2025, No. 24/58239; Paris Civil Court, expedited procedure on the merits, 10 October 2025, No. 25/52961; Paris Civil Court, summary proceedings, 10 October 2025, No. 25/53018; Roanne Commercial Court, summary proceedings, 21 November 2025, No. 2025R00012; Bordeaux Civil Court, 1st civil chamber, 18 December 2025, No. 24/06043; Évreux Civil Court, summary proceedings, 4 March 2026, No. 25/00469; Lille Civil Court, summary proceedings, 16 June 2026, No. 26/00532.
Une question sur ce sujet ?A question on this topic?
Décrivez votre situation en quelques lignes : nous vous recontactons.Describe your situation in a few lines and we will get back to you.
À lire aussi
Shareholder disputes in France: the complete guide
The remedies French company law offers when shareholders fall out, from negotiation to court-ordered dissolution.
NIS 2 Directive: what cybersecurity obligations for your company?
Who the NIS 2 Directive covers, what it requires, the sanctions it carries and where its transposition stands in France.